who said america is great because america is good

Alexis de Tocqueville was a 19th-century French diplomat, political scientist, and historian, best known for his two-volume work “Democracy in America” (published 1835 and 1840), in which he made his observations on American politics, society, and culture gleaned from his travels throughout the United States in 1831-32. , newspapers, books, and websites as a testament to the moral virtues of Christianity and/or America’s democratic institutions: Read: Who Says America Is Great Because America Is Good, And It’s Not There there. I searched for American greatness and genius in her fertile fields and endless forests, but it was not there. I looked for American greatness and genius in her rich mines and vast world trade, but it was not there. I looked for American greatness and genius in her public school system and institutions, but it wasn’t there. I looked for American greatness and genius in the democratic Congress and her unparalleled Constitution, but it was not there. It wasn’t until I went into churches in America and heard her pulpit burn with righteousness that I understood the secret of her talent and strength. America is great because she is good, and if America is no longer good, she will not be great.Read more: Who is Amanda Cerny’s boyfriend? Relationship time 2021 | Q&A back to top However, these words do not appear in the pages of “Democracy in America”, nor do they appear in any other texts or statements recorded around the same time as de. Tocqueville. Multiple sources have debunked de Tocqueville’s credit for more than 25 years, as seen in the following excerpt from a 1995 paper by John J. Pitney, Jr., associate professor of government at Claremont McKenna College: This line is very sublime and poetic. They are also fake. Nowhere do they appear in Democracy in America, or anywhere else in Tocqueville. used quotes. A student soon discovered a recent Senate speech that quoted the line “America is great”. He scoured Democracy in America, but couldn’t find the way. Other studies have resulted in reference books that conservatively refer to the citation as “unverified” and “attributed to de Tocqueville but not found in his writings.” These references, in turn, point to the obvious source: a 1941 book on religion and the American dream. The book quotes the last two lines of the passage from Democracy in America but does not provide documentation. (The author may have mistaken his own notes for a verbatim quote, a common problem in the days before photocopiers.) The full version of the quote appeared 11 years later, in a Eisenhower campaign speech. Ike, however, attributes it not directly to Tocqueville but to “a wise philosopher [who] came to this country…” One might surmise that the author of Eisenhower’s speech edited lines from the 1941 book and avoided mentioning Tocqueville directly as a cover-up. Lyricists often do such things.Read more: who does jon b marry | Similar Q&A, Ralph Keyes wrote in his 2006 book “Citation Verifiers” that there are no authentic documents that suggest the origin of these words is de Tocqueville’s own: Like sums Presidents Eisenhower and Reagan before him, Bill Clinton liked to attribute these words to Alexis de Tocqueville. Various other political figures, news commentators and patriotic orators have cited this statement, which is said to have been made by America’s most famous tourist. Researchers from the Library of Congress call the allocation “unverified”. They found the full quote, allegedly about Democracy in America, by de Tocqueville, in a 1941 book called Kingdom of God and the American Dream by missionary Sherwood Eddy (1871-1963). … Who actually wrote these words remains a mystery. Sherwood Eddy gives no source for his de Tocqueville attribution. According to biographer Rick L. Nutt, Eddy tends to work from memory. He probably read the 1908 copy of The Methodist Review, in which de Tocqueville is quoted as saying that he had searched in vain for the source of America’s differences until he entered a church. : “It was there, as I listened to the soul- The egalitarian and soul-elevating principles of the Gospel of Christ as they fell from Sabbath to Sabbath upon the masses of the people, that I had learned why America was great and free, and why France was a slave. These uncharacteristic words are not de Tocqueville’s either. Records of this passage to de Tocqueville have hitherto been recorded since 1887, and researcher Barry Popik discovered an undocumented variant published in 1886: I participated in the duel. your contractor, and through their Trade details. I went up the mountain and went down to their valley. I visited their manufacturing plants, trade markets and trading facilities. I walked into their judicial court and legislative hall. But I searched in vain for the secret of their success, until I entered the church. It was there, as I listened to the soul-equal and soul-elevating principles of the Gospel of Christ, as they fell from Sabbath to Sabbath upon the masses, that I learned at why America is great and free, and why France. A book published in 1835 by Andrew Reed and James Matheson, two English ministers who visited sister churches in the United States in 1834 to promote peace and friendship and then wrote about their travels. them, contains what may be the germ from which the quote sprouts: “America would be great if America was good. Otherwise, her greatness would vanish like a morning cloud. Whatever the ultimate origin, this quote emerges about how “America is great because she is good” has evolved over a long period of time independent of anything de Tocqueville actually wrote, and as part of that evolution, it retroactively (and forged) was assigned to him.Read more: ice man steve austin married | Top Q&A